MR Round Table: We Spoke to a Specialist About Food Anxiety

A follow up to our previous e-mail conversation on our thoughts about food.


Leandra Medine: At Man Repeller, we really try to have the hard conversations that we believe women are thinking but might be too afraid to talk about. That fear is rooted in shame and we’re trying to defeat shame by exhausting communication. I wrote about my fertility issues, we’ve spoken about anxiety attacks and recently, we had a conversation about food. It was about how much time we spend thinking about food and whether or not the relationships we have with food are healthy. That conversation left a lot of question marks unaccommodated. What we saw was an enormous amount of empathy. It made us realize that there’s a sort of epidemic plaguing our society and we probably need to do something about it if we can. Neither myself nor Amelia are specialists, though, so we are very grateful that you were able to speak with us.

Dr. Allegra Broft, a psychiatrist in the Eating Disorders Research Unit at the Columbia University Medical Center:  It’s a huge topic that you’re tackling. I work up at the Columbia Eating Research Group and I have a small private practice as well, so I deal with the most extreme types of problems. That gives me a good vantage point across the topic’s spectrum, though I deal a little less with the subtler struggles. However, I do think many, many women in America are entrapped by some version of overthinking food and overthinking shape and weight issues.

Leandra: What do you think that’s a result of?

Dr. Broft: It’s hard to speak in generalizations. When talking to eating disorder patients, one of the things they’ll often say is, “I hate it when I, as an eating disorder patient, am being put into a box as though I am just an eating disorder.” But we have some models that we use to think of where these disorders come from, and I think that they apply across a wide variety of smaller struggles.

One is the “cognitive-behavioral” model of eating problems. Whatever the problem is — whether it’s a restrictive eating problem (i.e., thinking about dieting all the time) or if it’s a binge-eating problem — much of that fixation with food, for many, has at some point involved some sort of shape and weight pre-occupation.

And where does that come from? Well that’s the “black box,” for most folks. These are the underlying issues that initiated or perpetuate weight or food preoccupation, which are not necessarily the same from person to person, and are sometimes hard to easily identify.

What are some themes of that “black box”? Things like a self-esteem issue, an identity problem: “Who am I in the world?” Someone could be biologically depressed and feel that focusing on shape and weight helps them escape. These are all put forward in a cognitive behavioral model for formal eating disorders, and I think can apply across the spectrum as well.

Leandra: There’s this very unique gray area of women who don’t necessarily identify themselves as having an eating disorder, but do identify themselves as having unusual eating habits. Are we actually disordered?

Dr. Broft: Even as a professional, I’m not sure if I can always make te call. How do we think of a disorder, whether it’s an eating problem or an anxiety problem? It’s where there’s a psychological experience that ends up taking over the way that you would otherwise function. Your social life becomes impaired; in the case of food it’s, “I don’t want to go out because I feel uncomfortable in my clothes,” or, “I can’t work in the way I’d like to because I’m ruminating about food all the time.” That’s usually where we draw the line, diagnostically.

And of course that becomes a gray zone, because some of us may worry about it a little bit. Maybe it interferes with our work for five or ten minutes, but is that enough to be considered full dysfunction? I’m not going to pretend to say I always know exactly where the line is with that.

Amelia Diamond: I’m sure that this exists in a multitude of industries, but you see it all the time in fashion and hear about it in dance: talking about our bodies in a messed up way is total day-to-day banter. “I’m too fat for skinny jeans,” is code for, “Where should we have dinner?”

Leandra: Dr. Broft, just before you arrived — I’m taking estrogen supplements right now so I’m extremely bloated — I lifted my shirt to show Amelia that I don’t fit into my pants.

Amelia: She did. And the biggest compliment in fashion is, “You look so thin.” When I leave New York City and do the, “Ugh, I’m so fat today” monologue, they’re like, “Why are you talking about this?” And I’m just like, “This is normal conversation in my world.”

Dr. Broft:  That’s a really good point. I think a lot of women are going there by default. It’s almost engrained. You’re doing such a wonderful thing by speaking about it now and asking, “Do we really have to go there?”

When I talk to patients across the spectrum, I ask, “What is the utility of labeling yourself in this way?” Or, “Your pants don’t fit today, is that really so bad?” The implication is that there is something terrible about it. So, it’s not the statement per se, but it’s where you go with it in your mind and what you think it means about yourself.

Amelia: Sort of like a habit?

Dr. Broft: It’s really interesting that you use that word. I do think of it that way. I get jazzed about the word “habit” because in our clinical research team, we’re thinking about habit in regards to neuroscience. We’re thinking about to what extent are these full-blown eating disorders mediated by the neural-circuitry that deeply engrains habits in our brains.

One of the things that cognitive therapy teaches us is the notion of automatic thought. That’s basically the idea that we all learn certain scripts or ways of thinking at a very young age. The example that we often talk about in cognitive therapy is when we first learn to tie our shoes. We don’t know how to do it in the beginning. We do it very slowly at first and have to give so much thought to that action. Once we master it, of course, we never think about tying our shoes again. It becomes an automatic script in our mind.

We have a way of doing this in other parts of our life, like in the way we think about ourselves and our bodies and food. At some point there was probably a slow process where we were learning to think certain foods are good and certain foods are bad. And now that’s all become so engrained that we don’t even think twice about it.

From a cognitive therapy perspective, we have this subset of automatic thoughts and cognitive distortions that we kick into gear and automatically think: my pants not fitting is a sign that life is terrible, or I am a slob. So yes, I think “habit” is a good word.

Amelia: Part of what we discussed in our food conversation is how to actually talk about these things, and what’s okay to say. I read a book once where the author, who had an eating disorder, explained how hard it is for people to write about this topic because it’s so easy to trigger readers who have eating disorders. She wrote that girls in school can learn how to practice disordered eating by reading about it in school text books. So how do you teach it? How do you write about it? How do you talk about it?

Dr. Broft: It’s true. And I don’t know what to say about that issue. It’s like doing this interview: how do we walk the line? Hopefully, we get some messages across that are really helpful about how we approach our bodies and ourselves in a healthy way.

In the field, in general, we do shy away from suggesting reading to patients for exactly the reasons you’re talking about. I don’t have the answer as far as exactly how that line is established because there is lot of danger.

Amelia: Do you think there’s danger in speaking about it in the way that we did publicly, talking about our anxieties and thoughts?

Leandra: And trying to figure out whether or not there is such thing as a healthy relationship with food.

Dr. Broft: I think that…as with any opening up of this discussion, there’s always the potential of other people expressing their own anxieties, and their own ideas may feed people in a not-so helpful way. Or maybe it helps other people realize a problem that they didn’t acknowledge before.

Amelia: What surprised us was that a lot of these comments said, “Me too.”

Leandra: Which is why I’m really curious about whether or not there is such thing as a healthy relationship with food. Are there women who don’t spend any time thinking about it? Who are like, “It must be so exhausting to live in your head.” I’m not sure.

Do you find that a lot of people in your field become specialists because they’ve experienced the plight themselves?

Dr. Broft: Actually, one of the larger eating disorder recovery centers in the country, Monte Nido, is run by somebody who is very open about the fact that she struggled.

Some patients say there’s nothing like talking to somebody who previously struggled with this as well in terms of really connecting and empathizing. On the other hand, that can become complicated. If the therapist has really worked through her issues and can manage the complicated element of having struggled to be objective with others and bring a recovered attitude towards treatment, that’s one thing. But it can be complicated and triggering for women or people who have struggled.

Amelia: You’ve referred to women a lot. I know men can have eating disorders, but it is primarily female problem, right?

Dr. Broft: Statistically, of all those who struggle with anorexia or bulimia, the breakdown is 90% women, 10% men.

Leandra: If we could help positively affect the construction of the psyche of a girl who is just entering the phase of her life where she is becoming influenced by the thought of food and what her body looks like, what do you think is the type of advice that we should be giving her?

Dr. Broft: It’s something like: if you start turning to a diet to control your shape and weight as a solution to feeling good in the world, stop yourself from going there.

Leandra: Meaning…don’t react to a symptom and assume that this symptom is the problem?

Dr: Broft: Yes, something like that. It’s such a good question. It’s obviously to the core. A New York Times article was recently published addressing “design thinking.” The author wanted to lose weight to the point that it preoccupied her thoughts. The idea of this “design” perspective is to try to first find empathy toward a problem or within yourself, and then to take the perspective of, “If I want this, what is it that I’m really trying to solve?” She was fixated on her weight, but design thinking made her ask: What do I really need? Why do I really want to lose 25 pounds? She wanted more social connection, she wanted a sense of community and to have more energy. She was then able to tackle those issues directly.

I think that speaks to some element of what a lot of women are looking for: they want to look better, they want to feel more socially or romantically confident. So he started peeling it back and thought, “If that’s what I’m looking for, do I really want to put all the focus on weight? I want to think about how I can amp up my social connections. Do I need to get myself out there more?”

Leandra: That’s very self-aware.

Dr. Broft: I think that’s the idea: What is the real problem here? If you’re focused on weight, that can’t be “it.”

Amelia: I don’t have anywhere near the body of like, Kayla Itsines — a fitness celebrity on Instagram — but I’m not going to lie: I’d like to. What if you’re like me, i.e., not overweight, feeling fine most of the time, but want to lose some weight. When does that become a problem?

Dr. Broft: Well, why are any of us trying to look like anyone besides ourselves? You have to ask yourself, “Am I happy about the way I am?” If the answer is yes, then screw it. Of course, talking to a neutral source is one way of reality-testing yourself along those lines.

Amelia: In other words, if you’re concerned, consult a professional.

Dr. Broft: Yes, that’s always a message that I believe in delivering.

Leandra: I think the other thing, though, in asking if you like how you look, is trying to strip away how much you value yourself and if it’s contingent on you comparing yourself to other people. Are you historically comparative? That’s something that happens to me with my anxiety. When I’m not comparing myself to, for example, another female entrepreneur who’s done X, Y, and Z better than I have, I feel much better about what I’ve built. But when I am, I feel like I’m not doing anything constructive. When I’m comparing my current self to my former self — looking at Man Repeller as a business I’ve built myself independent of anything else — I feel very proud.

Dr. Broft: Which model works better?

Leandra: Obviously the one where I feel proud, as long as it doesn’t affect my humility!

Dr. Broft: I think it’s a really good example. That’s really what you want to think about. What is the purpose of comparison? It just doesn’t serve most of us well.

Leandra: Yeah, it’s like malignant motivation.

Dr. Broft: A lot of us are used to needing that — looking toward those external sources that whip us into shape to move forward, so I think that’s a brain tendency that a lot of us have and yet, what does it do? It leaves us feeling shameful or guilty or inferior. So it doesn’t work very well, even though some of us have learned to drive a lot of motivation from it.

Leandra: It’s so baked into our culture, right? To compare ourselves to others in order to become better as ourselves. But all that stuff is within us, we just have to work to break down the negative tendencies and with healthy self-awareness, keep trying to cultivate these new ones.

To learn more about eating disorders and healthy eating practices, Dr. Broft recommends “The Rules of ‘Normal’ Eating” by Karen R. Koenig, “Intuitive Eating” by Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch, “Overcoming Binge Eating” by Christopher G. Fairburn. For more information, visit the Columbia Center for Eating Disorders, as well as a blog on eating disorders maintained by Dr. Broft’s team.

Photographed by Krista Anna Lewis



Get more Brain Massage ?
  • Chantel

    Interesting article.

  • Aydan

    Ladies, this was incredibly interesting!! Thank you so much for walking the line (and even when you cross it) for all of us readers, its refreshing and just sooo sooo necessary!

    (Also as an aside: would it be possible to bold the name of who is talking all the way through, I feel like these conversations can get visually messy without some sort of visual cue to allow us to see when a new person it talking — especially if one person’s dialogue is across mult. paragraphs! THANK YOU!!)

    • Leandra Medine

      Yes, definitely! Thanks for the feedback, Aydan.

      • Sandra Smith

        When I looked at the draft of 7986 dollars, I accept that my friend’s brother was like really creating cash in his free time with his PC. . His aunt’s neighbor has done this for only 10 months and by now repaid the loan on their home and bought a new Car . Look here for details.

        CLICK Here To Discover More


  • *PRAISE HANDS* for this round table! Thank you for walking the line and bringing this issue to the light. As someone with food anxiety and a fractured relationship with food, I spent years and years ignoring the underlying issues causing my fixation on food and a binge-then-restrict cycle. It’s only been the past few months that I realized that the mindset I had about my health and wellness in general was not (and should not be) normal!

    Again, thank you for this insightful and intelligent conversation!

    • Doris Jones

      When I looked at the draft of 6986 dollars, I accept that my friend’s brother was like really creating cash in his free time with his PC. . His aunt’s neighbor has done this for only 10 months and by now repaid the loan on their home and bought a new Car . Look here for details.

      CLICK Here To Discover More


  • an honest, intelligent conversation! thank you!

  • olive

    Awesome. I am glad this conversation is being brought up addressing the spectrum of issues and sources of these issues, and on top of that asking the question: “is this even a problem?”

    Where that line is drawn I think is probably different for everyone, but understanding the gray areas, and the existence of them, I think is one of the most important things for self-awareness.

    I have struggled with some version of overthinking food for years now. I have never gotten extremely dangerous with it, but I have always tried to convince myself I didn’t have a problem because no one could see one. But I knew, that the way it was affecting my social life, work, and morale, was an issue that I still am struggling with, and this slides the scale as being normally health-conscious planning my meals, to overthinking every crumb that enters my mouth.

    Still something I’m working on, and thank you for starting a healthy conversation!

  • Maia Binhammer

    This was such a great follow-up to your last discussion. Really good.

  • Adardame

    I lost weight the other year, and while it’s considerably more comfortable physically, it didn’t do anything for my self-esteem. That requires a different kind of catharsis.

  • Hannah Cole

    Thankyou thankyou for doing this.
    I found myself falling into the habit of always talking about myself with the “fat” adjective last year – no matter how I truly felt. My resolution for 2016 – stop using it in that way. Renewing my mind, refreshing it, getting out of the habit to stop believing the crazy things I tell myself sometimes. So far, so good.

  • kay

    the part at the end about comparisons and being a comparative person, there is just so much there. the flip side of what leandra was saying is, in my opinion, that most people do some form of that to make themselves feel better, especially as women, like saying to yourself “at least I’m not as fat/ugly/unsuccessful as that girl” and part of the fear about comparisons is the knowledge that other people are looking at you and thinking how lucky they are to not be you. this is totally awful, and the root of all evil in my opinion, but it’s amazing, if you really watch yourself in a day, how much you do it without even really thinking about it. especially if you are having a bad day and are trying to make yourself feel better. this is different from what leandra was saying- it seems like she was more talking about comparisons about who is at the top, and i’m thinking about comparisons that are preoccupied with fear of being the last one at the bottom, but i totally agree that comparative thinking is deep in our culture, maybe in our monkey brains as humans. but since we are humans with imagination, it’s not the only option for how to think about things, luckily. and with that i just compared my species to other poor unfortunate species with no imaginations. ugh its everywhere.

  • Jacqueline

    I loved this article.

  • I have a few male friends that have gained weight as they move further and further away from that adolescent metabolism as well as closer to a more sedentary lifestyle (i.e. WORKLIFE) and people have openly told them they’ve gotten fatter and they agreed and did something about it (or didn’t). There was nothing emotional, merely the acknowledgement that calories in were piling faster than calories out.

    I envy that.

    For me, it feels so much more intertwined with feelings of shame, and anger. I hate that. I think you always remember the first time someone other than yourself calls you fat. And while I mostly tune out the body obsession because my brain isn’t interested –there’s too much tv to watch, sometimes that “well-meaning” relative gives you unsolicited advice when you least expect it and it’s just a punch to your (apparently paunchier) gut.

    And then every comment becomes pointed. And I hate Them (whoever you are) for caring how I look, for thinking I care, for making me care –for all the wrong reasons.

    What do you mean when you ask me if I exercise? Is this a general conversation topic because health is important or are you insinuating something?

    What do you mean when you say to be careful not to eat too many potatoes because they make you fat? Is that just general advice or do you think I’m at risk of being (gasp) chubby?

    What do you mean when you tell all the guys to eat up and then “politely” tell me to “eat at my own risk?

    What do you mean when you keep calling yourself fat when we’re about the same size? Do you think I’m fat too?

    What do you mean when you tell me exercise is important to be healthy but to be careful not to run too much, it will make my leg muscles too bulky?

    What do you mean when you say I look thinner (after doing literally nothing differently–consciously at least)? Did you think I looked fat before?

    Why did you ask me if I’m afraid of getting fat when I declined (albeit repeatedly) to eat a slice of cake ( I didn’t eat it because it looked like bad cake) ?

    Am I really fat? Or just fat-er because I’m no longer (naturally) underweight?

    Do I need you to tell me? Am I oblivious? In denial?

    How can you tell someone they’ve gotten chubby with it simply equating to possible unhealthiness rather than a cosmetic issue?

    And while I try my best shrug off any food hang up legacies I unwillingly inherited from elders and peers, family and friends and acquaintances alike, I vow to pass on as little of these neuroses I can (hopefully none).

  • meme

    90% women, 10% men. So difficult not to analize this from a feminist perspective.
    So I say screw it, be happy with your own body. But at the same time, I fear that this mindset is a protection not to go into the shitty emotional places obsessing about my weight has taken me in the past, even though I have gained a bit of weight and I am not very physically active, which are things that I should probably change for health reasons.
    So how do you know what is healthy and what is just allowing pathriarchy to screw up your sense of self?

  • BK

    In the amount of time I reserve for thinking about the love triangle that is food, exercise, and my size, I could probably build an entire house, by hand, alone. Including making my own bricks.

    • I need to remember this in the future. I’ve already conquered minimizing anxiety about what I wear to work with a similar approach

  • Liz

    Good interview. Cakespy just wrote a post about this very topic that I literally *just* finished before cruising on over to MR, and this article was front and center. Coincidence? Probably. But it certainly made me reflect HARD on my own issues as someone in ED recovery. Bringing this type of banter that women have as our ‘default’ between one another to the forefront and calling it out for what it is– bullshit– is a big step to getting this to change. We ladies spend so much mental energy on hating our own bodies that I shudder to think of what we *could* accomplish if that energy were directed elsewhere. As played as I feel like the whole “Love your body!” movement is (especially in a fucked-up advertising world where that message is parked next to VS models and such). I’m trying to embrace who I am, physical included, and see what positive things might happen. Shit, I may up end up liking myself.


  • FeministFatal

    I really appreciate this. I’ve been asking myself this exact question a lot lately, where do you draw the line between disordered eating and healthy eating? I eat pretty healthy most of the time and am not anal about never indulging but I know I think about it a little obsessively and definitely not for the right reasons. My two closest friends are recovering from eating disorders and I don’t feel like I can talk to them about it because I am worried they will tell me I am headed down that path (and I honestly don’t want to hear it even if that may be true) or that it will trigger something for them. Thank you so much for using your platform to talk about these issues candidly!

  • kevynryan

    Guilty all day long. I am almost 29 and thank god past the point of wondering what the f is wrong with me that I can’t just EAT and stop THINKING about it. Turns out it’s not that uncommon, but I think it needs to be talked about more. A lot more. So thank you.

  • Sissy C

    Leandra, I can’t believe you want a bod like Kayla’s. Everyday I want a bod like yours! You look so good in your jeans!

  • soniadelvalle

    I want to believe that I now have a much more healthy relathionship with food than I did back in highschool when I was starving myself to be as thin as possible. Now I’m 100% more concerned about working out to be fit (read as strong, energetic and happy with my body).
    This made me realize that with my friends, the words “fat” or “weight” are never mentioned. We encourage each other to work out, but we never comment on the tightness of our pants and we never shy away from pizza. Not on some previous agreement or anything, I just realize it’s not part of our vocabulary, at least with each other. However, when I look at pictures of skinny models on pinterest, the little voice inside still says “oh I wish I looked like that”.

  • Carmen

    I’m wondering if “food anxiety” is simply a euphemism for weight issues. The article, to me, is really about weight anxiety, which is expressed through food obsession. The bit about Design Thinking is pretty brilliant. When I start to think about what losing weight or being the ideal weight would gain me, I realize how I’ve created a false logic — the things aren’t logically connected to my weight, in my warped mind.

    I’m also wondering if there’s anyone who is a size 8-10, my size, in the fashion industry. It’s a difficult range because it doesn’t fit into the “fit” category or in the “plus size and proud” category. And rarely do sites, such as this one, ever feature anyone in this size range. I wonder if MR feels some accountability about representation in this way, because articles such as this just show what we all already know, thin people already in the industry have a platform to engage in the difficult conversations of body issues from a privileged, already-made-it pedestal. Is anyone on staff above a size 4?